今天测试hotmail遇到奇怪事儿，大家看日志

tdk

我用opera mail 从我的服务器给hotmail发送邮邮件 日志如下：
你们看看是发出去了没有？

1. 
   
2. [20/Jun/2008 15:12:51][1188] {smtps} SMTP server session begin; client connected from 61.61.61.61:6044
   
3. [20/Jun/2008 15:12:51][1188] {smtps} Looking up address 61.61.61.61 in DNS blacklist SpamCop...
   
4. [20/Jun/2008 15:12:51][1188] {smtps} Address 61.61.61.61.bl.spamcop.net not found in DNS blacklist SpamCop
   
5. [20/Jun/2008 15:12:51][1188] {smtps} Looking up address 61.61.61.61 in DNS blacklist 国内cbl-...
   
6. [20/Jun/2008 15:12:51][1188] {smtps} Address 61.61.61.61.cblless.anti-spam.org.cn not found in DNS blacklist 国内cbl-
   
7. [20/Jun/2008 15:12:51][1188] {smtps} Looking up address 61.61.61.61 in DNS blacklist WPBL - Weighted Private Block List...
   
8. [20/Jun/2008 15:12:51][1188] {smtps} Address 61.61.61.61.db.wpbl.info not found in DNS blacklist WPBL - Weighted Private Block List
   
9. [20/Jun/2008 15:12:51][1188] {smtps} Looking up address 61.61.61.61 in DNS blacklist SpamHaus SBL-XBL...
   
10. [20/Jun/2008 15:12:51][1188] {smtps} Address 61.61.61.61.sbl-xbl.spamhaus.org not found in DNS blacklist SpamHaus SBL-XBL
    
11. [20/Jun/2008 15:12:51][1188] {smtps} Looking up address 61.61.61.61 in DNS blacklist Distributed Sender Blackhole List - unconfirmed...
    
12. [20/Jun/2008 15:12:52][1188] {smtps} Address 61.61.61.61.unconfirmed.dsbl.org not found in DNS blacklist Distributed Sender Blackhole List - unconfirmed
    
13. [20/Jun/2008 15:12:52][1188] {smtps} Looking up address 61.61.61.61 in DNS blacklist Distributed Sender Blackhole List - trusted...
    
14. [20/Jun/2008 15:12:52][1188] {smtps} Address 61.61.61.61.list.dsbl.org not found in DNS blacklist Distributed Sender Blackhole List - trusted
    
15. [20/Jun/2008 15:12:52][1188] {smtps} Delaying SMTP greeting to 61.61.61.61:6044 for 15 seconds
    
16. [20/Jun/2008 15:13:07][1188] {smtps} Sent SMTP greeting to 61.61.61.61:6044
    
17. [20/Jun/2008 15:13:07][1188] {smtps} Command EHLO xdsc-host
    
18. [20/Jun/2008 15:13:07][1188] {smtps} Sent reply to EHLO: 250 mail.mydomain.com.cn ...
    
19. [20/Jun/2008 15:13:07][1188] {smtps} Command AUTH CRAM-MD5
    
20. [20/Jun/2008 15:13:07][1188] {smtps} Started authentication method CRAM-MD5
    
21. [20/Jun/2008 15:13:07][1188] {smtps} Sent reply to AUTH: 235 2.0.0 Authentication successful (user abcd@mydomain.com.cn)
    
22. [20/Jun/2008 15:13:07][1188] {smtps} Command MAIL FROM:<abcd@mydomain.com.cn>
    
23. [20/Jun/2008 15:13:07][1188] {smtps} Sent reply to MAIL: 250 2.1.0 Sender <abcd@mydomain.com.cn> ok
    
24. [20/Jun/2008 15:13:07][1188] {smtps} Command RCPT TO:<tdk@hotmail.com>
    
25. [20/Jun/2008 15:13:07][1188] {smtps} Sent reply to RCPT: 250 2.1.5 Recipient <tdk@hotmail.com> ok (remote)
    
26. [20/Jun/2008 15:13:07][1188] {smtps} Command DATA
    
27. [20/Jun/2008 15:13:08][1188] {smtps} 548 bytes received in command DATA
    
28. [20/Jun/2008 15:13:08][1188] {smtps} Message accepted for delivery
    
29. [20/Jun/2008 15:13:08][1188] {smtps} Command QUIT
    
30. [20/Jun/2008 15:13:08][1188] {smtps} SMTP server session end

复制代码

答案是hotmail没有邮件，包括垃圾邮件夹。
而我用foxmail发送同样邮件，hotmail 两秒内收到，且在正常收件夹。
foxmail发信时候日志如下：

1. 
   
2. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:31][2020] {smtps} SMTP server session begin; client connected from 61.61.61.61:18103
   
3. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:31][2020] {smtps} Looking up address 61.61.61.61 in DNS blacklist SpamCop...
   
4. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:32][2020] {smtps} Address 61.61.61.61.bl.spamcop.net not found in DNS blacklist SpamCop
   
5. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:32][2020] {smtps} Looking up address 61.61.61.61 in DNS blacklist 国内cbl-...
   
6. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:32][2020] {smtps} Address 61.61.61.61.cblless.anti-spam.org.cn not found in DNS blacklist 国内cbl-
   
7. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:32][2020] {smtps} Looking up address 61.61.61.61 in DNS blacklist WPBL - Weighted Private Block List...
   
8. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:32][2020] {smtps} Address 61.61.61.61.db.wpbl.info not found in DNS blacklist WPBL - Weighted Private Block List
   
9. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:32][2020] {smtps} Looking up address 61.61.61.61 in DNS blacklist SpamHaus SBL-XBL...
   
10. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:32][2020] {smtps} Address 61.61.61.61.sbl-xbl.spamhaus.org not found in DNS blacklist SpamHaus SBL-XBL
    
11. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:32][2020] {smtps} Looking up address 61.61.61.61 in DNS blacklist Distributed Sender Blackhole List - unconfirmed...
    
12. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:32][2020] {smtps} Address 61.61.61.61.unconfirmed.dsbl.org not found in DNS blacklist Distributed Sender Blackhole List - unconfirmed
    
13. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:32][2020] {smtps} Looking up address 61.61.61.61 in DNS blacklist Distributed Sender Blackhole List - trusted...
    
14. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:32][2020] {smtps} Address 61.61.61.61.list.dsbl.org not found in DNS blacklist Distributed Sender Blackhole List - trusted
    
15. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:32][2020] {smtps} Delaying SMTP greeting to 61.61.61.61:18103 for 15 seconds
    
16. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:47][2020] {smtps} Sent SMTP greeting to 61.61.61.61:18103
    
17. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:47][2020] {smtps} Command EHLO xdsc-host
    
18. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:47][2020] {smtps} Sent reply to EHLO: 250 mail.mydomain.com.cn ...
    
19. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:47][2020] {smtps} Command AUTH LOGIN
    
20. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:47][2020] {smtps} Started authentication method LOGIN
    
21. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:48][2020] {smtps} Sent reply to AUTH: 235 2.0.0 Authentication successful (user abcd@mydomain.com.cn)
    
22. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:48][2020] {smtps} Command MAIL FROM: <abcd@mydomain.com.cn> SIZE=2251
    
23. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:48][2020] {smtps} Sent reply to MAIL: 250 2.1.0 Sender <abcd@mydomain.com.cn> ok
    
24. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:48][2020] {smtps} Command RCPT TO: <tdk@hotmail.com>
    
25. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:48][2020] {smtps} Sent reply to RCPT: 250 2.1.5 Recipient <tdk@hotmail.com> ok (remote)
    
26. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:48][2020] {smtps} Command Data
    
27. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:48][2020] {smtps} 2256 bytes received in command DATA
    
28. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:48][2020] {smtps} Message accepted for delivery
    
29. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:48][2020] {smtps} Command QUIT
    
30. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:48][2020] {smtps} SMTP server session end

复制代码

仔细看一下，好像就是认证方式不一样..... 我有点糊涂了
hotmail 搞什么鬼？还是我哪儿每注意到
大家帮我分析一下。

tdk

61.61.61.61 是我公司上网的出口，我的mailserver 测试机托管在外面机房。

dennishan

hotmail 特点：
1.发送邮件收不到（日志显示成功），估计针对某些IP设置了直接删除
2.发邮件偶尔收不到（估计有什么内容、邮件头策略）
3.hotmail发出的邮件，回复全部能够收到。

请TDK多做几次测试，有时结果会不太一样（也没准微软对Opera的东东有什么过滤）

dennishan

TDK，你贴的不是你服务器-》hotmail的，是客户端-》你服务器的日志吧。

tdk

多谢
1.应该不会，因为foxmail可以发到，webmail更没问题

下午又测了几次，还是一样结果，也许真的对opera做了什么？ 有点奇怪，
opera同样一封邮件发送sina等是可以的，说明opera mail我配置没问题（我也是第一次用operamail）

这几天用了用opera 9.5 感觉速度很快，所以附带测了一下发邮件，就出了这样的怪事儿 呵呵

tdk

原帖由 dennishan 于 2008-6-20 17:28 发表
TDK，你贴的不是你服务器-》hotmail的，是客户端-》你服务器的日志吧。

是我的服务器smtp日志  还有mail日志也显示成功

tdk

kerio的日志和md merak不太一样
开启debug后很多详细信息都是在一起的  没有独立分出smtp in  和 smtp out

tdk

晚上有空再把mail日志贴上来，都是2.0.0的成功

dennishan

1.我试用了opera mail 9.5，没有任何问题，hotmail立即收到，测试了2次，不过opera中文界面字体很怪。
2.贴出的日志我仔细看了，没有和hotmail有任何会话记录。
3.hotmail采用综合评分系统，是否会对opera的增加评分，这个谁都不知道了：），TDK可以去除opera发邮件的签名看看。
4.opera比IE好不了多少，打开新浪，占用CPU更高。

tdk

今天网络慢的出奇，现在补上mail 日志
opera 发送

1. [20/Jun/2008 15:13:08] Recv: Queue-ID: 485b5883-000003df, Service: SMTP, From: <abcd@mydomain.com.cn>, To: <tdk@hotmail.com>, Size: 728, Sender-Host: 61.61.61.61, User: abcd@mydomain.com.cn
   
2. [20/Jun/2008 15:13:11] Sent: Queue-ID: 485b5883-000003df, Recipient: <tdk@hotmail.com>, Result: relayed, Status: 2.0.0

复制代码

foxmail 发送

1. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:48] Recv: Queue-ID: 485b59d8-000003e1, Service: SMTP, From: <abcd@mydomain.com.cn>, To: <tdk@hotmail.com>, Size: 2436, Sender-Host: 61.61.61.61, User: abcd@mydomain.com.cn
   
2. [20/Jun/2008 15:18:51] Sent: Queue-ID: 485b59d8-000003e1, Recipient: <tdk@hotmail.com>, Result: relayed, Status: 2.0.0

复制代码